tailscale/ipn/auditlog/extension.go

199 lines
6.4 KiB
Go
Raw Normal View History

// Copyright (c) Tailscale Inc & AUTHORS
// SPDX-License-Identifier: BSD-3-Clause
package auditlog
import (
"context"
"errors"
"fmt"
"sync"
"time"
"tailscale.com/control/controlclient"
"tailscale.com/feature"
"tailscale.com/ipn"
"tailscale.com/ipn/ipnauth"
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
"tailscale.com/ipn/ipnext"
"tailscale.com/tailcfg"
"tailscale.com/tsd"
"tailscale.com/types/lazy"
"tailscale.com/types/logger"
)
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
// featureName is the name of the feature implemented by this package.
// It is also the [extension] name and the log prefix.
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
const featureName = "auditlog"
func init() {
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
feature.Register(featureName)
ipnext.RegisterExtension(featureName, newExtension)
}
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
// extension is an [ipnext.Extension] managing audit logging
// on platforms that import this package.
// As of 2025-03-27, that's only Windows and macOS.
type extension struct {
logf logger.Logf
// cleanup are functions to call on shutdown.
cleanup []func()
// store is the log store shared by all loggers.
// It is created when the first logger is started.
store lazy.SyncValue[LogStore]
// mu protects all following fields.
mu sync.Mutex
// logger is the current audit logger, or nil if it is not set up,
// such as before the first control client is created, or after
// a profile change and before the new control client is created.
//
// It queues, persists, and sends audit logs to the control client.
logger *Logger
}
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
// newExtension is an [ipnext.NewExtensionFn] that creates a new audit log extension.
// It is registered with [ipnext.RegisterExtension] if the package is imported.
func newExtension(logf logger.Logf, _ *tsd.System) (ipnext.Extension, error) {
return &extension{logf: logger.WithPrefix(logf, featureName+": ")}, nil
}
// Name implements [ipnext.Extension].
func (e *extension) Name() string {
return featureName
}
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
// Init implements [ipnext.Extension] by registering callbacks and providers
// for the duration of the extension's lifetime.
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
func (e *extension) Init(h ipnext.Host) error {
e.cleanup = []func(){
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
h.RegisterControlClientCallback(e.controlClientChanged),
ipn/{auditlog,ipnext,ipnlocal}: convert the profile-change callback to a profile-state-change callback In this PR, we enable extensions to track changes in the current prefs. These changes can result from a profile switch or from the user or system modifying the current profile’s prefs. Since some extensions may want to distinguish between the two events, while others may treat them similarly, we rename the existing profile-change callback to become a profile-state-change callback and invoke it whenever the current profile or its preferences change. Extensions can still use the sameNode parameter to distinguish between situations where the profile information, including its preferences, has been updated but still represents the same tailnet node, and situations where a switch to a different profile has been made. Having dedicated prefs-change callbacks is being considered, but currently seems redundant. A single profile-state-change callback is easier to maintain. We’ll revisit the idea of adding a separate callback as we progress on extracting existing features from LocalBackend, but the conversion to a profile-state-change callback is intended to be permanent. Finally, we let extensions retrieve the current prefs or profile state (profile info + prefs) at any time using the new CurrentProfileState and CurrentPrefs methods. We also simplify the NewControlClientCallback signature to exclude profile prefs. It’s optional, and extensions can retrieve the current prefs themselves if needed. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#27502 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-14 10:45:08 -05:00
h.Profiles().RegisterProfileStateChangeCallback(e.profileChanged),
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
h.RegisterAuditLogProvider(e.getCurrentLogger),
}
return nil
}
// [controlclient.Auto] implements [Transport].
var _ Transport = (*controlclient.Auto)(nil)
// startNewLogger creates and starts a new logger for the specified profile
// using the specified [controlclient.Client] as the transport.
// The profileID may be "" if the profile has not been persisted yet.
func (e *extension) startNewLogger(cc controlclient.Client, profileID ipn.ProfileID) (*Logger, error) {
transport, ok := cc.(Transport)
if !ok {
return nil, fmt.Errorf("%T cannot be used as transport", cc)
}
// Create a new log store if this is the first logger.
// Otherwise, get the existing log store.
store, err := e.store.GetErr(func() (LogStore, error) {
return newDefaultLogStore(e.logf)
})
if err != nil {
return nil, fmt.Errorf("failed to create audit log store: %w", err)
}
logger := NewLogger(Opts{
Logf: e.logf,
RetryLimit: 32,
Store: store,
})
if err := logger.SetProfileID(profileID); err != nil {
return nil, fmt.Errorf("set profile failed: %w", err)
}
if err := logger.Start(transport); err != nil {
return nil, fmt.Errorf("start failed: %w", err)
}
return logger, nil
}
ipn/{auditlog,ipnext,ipnlocal}: convert the profile-change callback to a profile-state-change callback In this PR, we enable extensions to track changes in the current prefs. These changes can result from a profile switch or from the user or system modifying the current profile’s prefs. Since some extensions may want to distinguish between the two events, while others may treat them similarly, we rename the existing profile-change callback to become a profile-state-change callback and invoke it whenever the current profile or its preferences change. Extensions can still use the sameNode parameter to distinguish between situations where the profile information, including its preferences, has been updated but still represents the same tailnet node, and situations where a switch to a different profile has been made. Having dedicated prefs-change callbacks is being considered, but currently seems redundant. A single profile-state-change callback is easier to maintain. We’ll revisit the idea of adding a separate callback as we progress on extracting existing features from LocalBackend, but the conversion to a profile-state-change callback is intended to be permanent. Finally, we let extensions retrieve the current prefs or profile state (profile info + prefs) at any time using the new CurrentProfileState and CurrentPrefs methods. We also simplify the NewControlClientCallback signature to exclude profile prefs. It’s optional, and extensions can retrieve the current prefs themselves if needed. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#27502 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-14 10:45:08 -05:00
func (e *extension) controlClientChanged(cc controlclient.Client, profile ipn.LoginProfileView) (cleanup func()) {
logger, err := e.startNewLogger(cc, profile.ID())
e.mu.Lock()
e.logger = logger // nil on error
e.mu.Unlock()
if err != nil {
// If we fail to create or start the logger, log the error
// and return a nil cleanup function. There's nothing more
// we can do here.
//
// But [extension.getCurrentLogger] returns [noCurrentLogger]
// when the logger is nil. Since [noCurrentLogger] always
// fails with [errNoLogger], operations that must be audited
// but cannot will fail on platforms where the audit logger
// is enabled (i.e., the auditlog package is imported).
e.logf("[unexpected] %v", err)
return nil
}
return func() {
// Stop the logger when the control client shuts down.
ctx, cancel := context.WithTimeout(context.Background(), 5*time.Second)
defer cancel()
logger.FlushAndStop(ctx)
}
}
func (e *extension) profileChanged(profile ipn.LoginProfileView, _ ipn.PrefsView, sameNode bool) {
e.mu.Lock()
defer e.mu.Unlock()
switch {
case e.logger == nil:
// No-op if we don't have an audit logger.
case sameNode:
// The profile info has changed, but it represents the same node.
// This includes the case where the login has just been completed
// and the profile's [ipn.ProfileID] has been set for the first time.
if err := e.logger.SetProfileID(profile.ID()); err != nil {
e.logf("[unexpected] failed to set profile ID: %v", err)
}
default:
// The profile info has changed, and it represents a different node.
// We won't have an audit logger for the new profile until the new
// control client is created.
//
// We don't expect any auditable actions to be attempted in this state.
// But if they are, they will fail with [errNoLogger].
e.logger = nil
}
}
// errNoLogger is an error returned by [noCurrentLogger]. It indicates that
// the logger was unavailable when [ipnlocal.LocalBackend] requested it,
// such as when an auditable action was attempted before [LocalBackend.Start]
// was called for the first time or immediately after a profile change
// and before the new control client was created.
//
// This error is unexpected and should not occur in normal operation.
var errNoLogger = errors.New("[unexpected] no audit logger")
// noCurrentLogger is an [ipnauth.AuditLogFunc] returned by [extension.getCurrentLogger]
// when the logger is not available. It fails with [errNoLogger] on every call.
func noCurrentLogger(_ tailcfg.ClientAuditAction, _ string) error {
return errNoLogger
}
cmd/tailscaled,ipn/{auditlog,desktop,ipnext,ipnlocal},tsd: extract LocalBackend extension interfaces and implementation In this PR, we refactor the LocalBackend extension system, moving from direct callbacks to a more organized extension host model. Specifically, we: - Extract interface and callback types used by packages extending LocalBackend functionality into a new ipn/ipnext package. - Define ipnext.Host as a new interface that bridges extensions with LocalBackend. It enables extensions to register callbacks and interact with LocalBackend in a concurrency-safe, well-defined, and controlled way. - Move existing callback registration and invocation code from ipnlocal.LocalBackend into a new type called ipnlocal.ExtensionHost, implementing ipnext.Host. - Improve docs for existing types and methods while adding docs for the new interfaces. - Add test coverage for both the extracted and the new code. - Remove ipn/desktop.SessionManager from tsd.System since ipn/desktop is now self-contained. - Update existing extensions (e.g., ipn/auditlog and ipn/desktop) to use the new interfaces where appropriate. We're not introducing new callback and hook types (e.g., for ipn.Prefs changes) just yet, nor are we enhancing current callbacks, such as by improving conflict resolution when more than one extension tries to influence profile selection via a background profile resolver. These further improvements will be submitted separately. Updates #12614 Updates tailscale/corp#27645 Updates tailscale/corp#26435 Updates tailscale/corp#18342 Signed-off-by: Nick Khyl <nickk@tailscale.com>
2025-04-10 20:24:58 -05:00
// getCurrentLogger is an [ipnext.AuditLogProvider] registered with [ipnext.Host].
// It is called when [ipnlocal.LocalBackend] or an extension needs to audit an action.
//
// It returns a function that enqueues the audit log for the current profile,
// or [noCurrentLogger] if the logger is unavailable.
func (e *extension) getCurrentLogger() ipnauth.AuditLogFunc {
e.mu.Lock()
defer e.mu.Unlock()
if e.logger == nil {
return noCurrentLogger
}
return e.logger.Enqueue
}
// Shutdown implements [ipnlocal.Extension].
func (e *extension) Shutdown() error {
for _, f := range e.cleanup {
f()
}
e.cleanup = nil
return nil
}