zitadel/internal/api/oidc/server.go

211 lines
8.1 KiB
Go
Raw Normal View History

package oidc
import (
"context"
"log/slog"
"net/http"
"time"
"github.com/zitadel/logging"
"github.com/zitadel/oidc/v3/pkg/oidc"
"github.com/zitadel/oidc/v3/pkg/op"
"github.com/zitadel/zitadel/internal/api/authz"
"github.com/zitadel/zitadel/internal/auth/repository"
"github.com/zitadel/zitadel/internal/command"
"github.com/zitadel/zitadel/internal/crypto"
feat: restrict languages (#6931) * feat: return 404 or 409 if org reg disallowed * fix: system limit permissions * feat: add iam limits api * feat: disallow public org registrations on default instance * add integration test * test: integration * fix test * docs: describe public org registrations * avoid updating docs deps * fix system limits integration test * silence integration tests * fix linting * ignore strange linter complaints * review * improve reset properties naming * redefine the api * use restrictions aggregate * test query * simplify and test projection * test commands * fix unit tests * move integration test * support restrictions on default instance * also test GetRestrictions * self review * lint * abstract away resource owner * fix tests * configure supported languages * fix allowed languages * fix tests * default lang must not be restricted * preferred language must be allowed * change preferred languages * check languages everywhere * lint * test command side * lint * add integration test * add integration test * restrict supported ui locales * lint * lint * cleanup * lint * allow undefined preferred language * fix integration tests * update main * fix env var * ignore linter * ignore linter * improve integration test config * reduce cognitive complexity * compile * check for duplicates * remove useless restriction checks * review * revert restriction renaming * fix language restrictions * lint * generate * allow custom texts for supported langs for now * fix tests * cleanup * cleanup * cleanup * lint * unsupported preferred lang is allowed * fix integration test * finish reverting to old property name * finish reverting to old property name * load languages * refactor(i18n): centralize translators and fs * lint * amplify no validations on preferred languages * fix integration test * lint * fix resetting allowed languages * test unchanged restrictions
2023-12-05 11:12:01 +00:00
"github.com/zitadel/zitadel/internal/i18n"
"github.com/zitadel/zitadel/internal/query"
"github.com/zitadel/zitadel/internal/telemetry/tracing"
)
type Server struct {
http.Handler
*op.LegacyServer
repo repository.Repository
query *query.Queries
command *command.Commands
accessTokenKeySet *oidcKeySet
idTokenHintKeySet *oidcKeySet
defaultLoginURL string
defaultLoginURLV2 string
defaultLogoutURLV2 string
defaultAccessTokenLifetime time.Duration
defaultIdTokenLifetime time.Duration
feat(oidc): use web keys for token signing and verification (#8449) # Which Problems Are Solved Use web keys, managed by the `resources/v3alpha/web_keys` API, for OIDC token signing and verification, as well as serving the public web keys on the jwks / keys endpoint. Response header on the keys endpoint now allows caching of the response. This is now "safe" to do since keys can be created ahead of time and caches have sufficient time to pickup the change before keys get enabled. # How the Problems Are Solved - The web key format is used in the `getSignerOnce` function in the `api/oidc` package. - The public key cache is changed to get and store web keys. - The jwks / keys endpoint returns the combined set of valid "legacy" public keys and all available web keys. - Cache-Control max-age default to 5 minutes and is configured in `defaults.yaml`. When the web keys feature is enabled, fallback mechanisms are in place to obtain and convert "legacy" `query.PublicKey` as web keys when needed. This allows transitioning to the feature without invalidating existing tokens. A small performance overhead may be noticed on the keys endpoint, because 2 queries need to be run sequentially. This will disappear once the feature is stable and the legacy code gets cleaned up. # Additional Changes - Extend legacy key lifetimes so that tests can be run on an existing database with more than 6 hours apart. - Discovery endpoint returns all supported algorithms when the Web Key feature is enabled. # Additional Context - Closes https://github.com/zitadel/zitadel/issues/8031 - Part of https://github.com/zitadel/zitadel/issues/7809 - After https://github.com/zitadel/oidc/pull/637 - After https://github.com/zitadel/oidc/pull/638
2024-08-23 12:43:46 +00:00
jwksCacheControlMaxAge time.Duration
fallbackLogger *slog.Logger
hasher *crypto.Hasher
signingKeyAlgorithm string
perf(oidc): optimize token creation (#7822) * implement code exchange * port tokenexchange to v2 tokens * implement refresh token * implement client credentials * implement jwt profile * implement device token * cleanup unused code * fix current unit tests * add user agent unit test * unit test domain package * need refresh token as argument * test commands create oidc session * test commands device auth * fix device auth build error * implicit for oidc session API * implement authorize callback handler for legacy implicit mode * upgrade oidc module to working draft * add missing auth methods and time * handle all errors in defer * do not fail auth request on error the oauth2 Go client automagically retries on any error. If we fail the auth request on the first error, the next attempt will always fail with the Errors.AuthRequest.NoCode, because the auth request state is already set to failed. The original error is then already lost and the oauth2 library does not return the original error. Therefore we should not fail the auth request. Might be worth discussing and perhaps send a bug report to Oauth2? * fix code flow tests by explicitly setting code exchanged * fix unit tests in command package * return allowed scope from client credential client * add device auth done reducer * carry nonce thru session into ID token * fix token exchange integration tests * allow project role scope prefix in client credentials client * gci formatting * do not return refresh token in client credentials and jwt profile * check org scope * solve linting issue on authorize callback error * end session based on v2 session ID * use preferred language and user agent ID for v2 access tokens * pin oidc v3.23.2 * add integration test for jwt profile and client credentials with org scopes * refresh token v1 to v2 * add user token v2 audit event * add activity trigger * cleanup and set panics for unused methods * use the encrypted code for v1 auth request get by code * add missing event translation * fix pipeline errors (hopefully) * fix another test * revert pointer usage of preferred language * solve browser info panic in device auth * remove duplicate entries in AMRToAuthMethodTypes to prevent future `mfa` claim * revoke v1 refresh token to prevent reuse * fix terminate oidc session * always return a new refresh toke in refresh token grant --------- Co-authored-by: Livio Spring <livio.a@gmail.com>
2024-05-16 05:07:56 +00:00
encAlg crypto.EncryptionAlgorithm
opCrypto op.Crypto
assetAPIPrefix func(ctx context.Context) string
}
func endpoints(endpointConfig *EndpointConfig) op.Endpoints {
// some defaults. The new Server will disable endpoints that are nil.
endpoints := op.Endpoints{
Authorization: op.NewEndpoint("/oauth/v2/authorize"),
Token: op.NewEndpoint("/oauth/v2/token"),
Introspection: op.NewEndpoint("/oauth/v2/introspect"),
Userinfo: op.NewEndpoint("/oidc/v1/userinfo"),
Revocation: op.NewEndpoint("/oauth/v2/revoke"),
EndSession: op.NewEndpoint("/oidc/v1/end_session"),
JwksURI: op.NewEndpoint("/oauth/v2/keys"),
DeviceAuthorization: op.NewEndpoint("/oauth/v2/device_authorization"),
}
if endpointConfig == nil {
return endpoints
}
if endpointConfig.Auth != nil {
endpoints.Authorization = op.NewEndpointWithURL(endpointConfig.Auth.Path, endpointConfig.Auth.URL)
}
if endpointConfig.Token != nil {
endpoints.Token = op.NewEndpointWithURL(endpointConfig.Token.Path, endpointConfig.Token.URL)
}
if endpointConfig.Introspection != nil {
endpoints.Introspection = op.NewEndpointWithURL(endpointConfig.Introspection.Path, endpointConfig.Introspection.URL)
}
if endpointConfig.Userinfo != nil {
endpoints.Userinfo = op.NewEndpointWithURL(endpointConfig.Userinfo.Path, endpointConfig.Userinfo.URL)
}
if endpointConfig.Revocation != nil {
endpoints.Revocation = op.NewEndpointWithURL(endpointConfig.Revocation.Path, endpointConfig.Revocation.URL)
}
if endpointConfig.EndSession != nil {
endpoints.EndSession = op.NewEndpointWithURL(endpointConfig.EndSession.Path, endpointConfig.EndSession.URL)
}
if endpointConfig.Keys != nil {
endpoints.JwksURI = op.NewEndpointWithURL(endpointConfig.Keys.Path, endpointConfig.Keys.URL)
}
if endpointConfig.DeviceAuth != nil {
endpoints.DeviceAuthorization = op.NewEndpointWithURL(endpointConfig.DeviceAuth.Path, endpointConfig.DeviceAuth.URL)
}
return endpoints
}
func (s *Server) getLogger(ctx context.Context) *slog.Logger {
if logger, ok := logging.FromContext(ctx); ok {
return logger
}
return s.fallbackLogger
}
func (s *Server) IssuerFromRequest(r *http.Request) string {
return s.Provider().IssuerFromRequest(r)
}
func (s *Server) Health(ctx context.Context, r *op.Request[struct{}]) (_ *op.Response, err error) {
ctx, span := tracing.NewSpan(ctx)
defer func() { span.EndWithError(err) }()
return s.LegacyServer.Health(ctx, r)
}
func (s *Server) Ready(ctx context.Context, r *op.Request[struct{}]) (_ *op.Response, err error) {
ctx, span := tracing.NewSpan(ctx)
defer func() { span.EndWithError(err) }()
return s.LegacyServer.Ready(ctx, r)
}
func (s *Server) Discovery(ctx context.Context, r *op.Request[struct{}]) (_ *op.Response, err error) {
ctx, span := tracing.NewSpan(ctx)
defer func() {
err = oidcError(err)
span.EndWithError(err)
}()
feat: restrict languages (#6931) * feat: return 404 or 409 if org reg disallowed * fix: system limit permissions * feat: add iam limits api * feat: disallow public org registrations on default instance * add integration test * test: integration * fix test * docs: describe public org registrations * avoid updating docs deps * fix system limits integration test * silence integration tests * fix linting * ignore strange linter complaints * review * improve reset properties naming * redefine the api * use restrictions aggregate * test query * simplify and test projection * test commands * fix unit tests * move integration test * support restrictions on default instance * also test GetRestrictions * self review * lint * abstract away resource owner * fix tests * configure supported languages * fix allowed languages * fix tests * default lang must not be restricted * preferred language must be allowed * change preferred languages * check languages everywhere * lint * test command side * lint * add integration test * add integration test * restrict supported ui locales * lint * lint * cleanup * lint * allow undefined preferred language * fix integration tests * update main * fix env var * ignore linter * ignore linter * improve integration test config * reduce cognitive complexity * compile * check for duplicates * remove useless restriction checks * review * revert restriction renaming * fix language restrictions * lint * generate * allow custom texts for supported langs for now * fix tests * cleanup * cleanup * cleanup * lint * unsupported preferred lang is allowed * fix integration test * finish reverting to old property name * finish reverting to old property name * load languages * refactor(i18n): centralize translators and fs * lint * amplify no validations on preferred languages * fix integration test * lint * fix resetting allowed languages * test unchanged restrictions
2023-12-05 11:12:01 +00:00
restrictions, err := s.query.GetInstanceRestrictions(ctx)
if err != nil {
return nil, op.NewStatusError(oidc.ErrServerError().WithParent(err).WithReturnParentToClient(authz.GetFeatures(ctx).DebugOIDCParentError).WithDescription("internal server error"), http.StatusInternalServerError)
feat: restrict languages (#6931) * feat: return 404 or 409 if org reg disallowed * fix: system limit permissions * feat: add iam limits api * feat: disallow public org registrations on default instance * add integration test * test: integration * fix test * docs: describe public org registrations * avoid updating docs deps * fix system limits integration test * silence integration tests * fix linting * ignore strange linter complaints * review * improve reset properties naming * redefine the api * use restrictions aggregate * test query * simplify and test projection * test commands * fix unit tests * move integration test * support restrictions on default instance * also test GetRestrictions * self review * lint * abstract away resource owner * fix tests * configure supported languages * fix allowed languages * fix tests * default lang must not be restricted * preferred language must be allowed * change preferred languages * check languages everywhere * lint * test command side * lint * add integration test * add integration test * restrict supported ui locales * lint * lint * cleanup * lint * allow undefined preferred language * fix integration tests * update main * fix env var * ignore linter * ignore linter * improve integration test config * reduce cognitive complexity * compile * check for duplicates * remove useless restriction checks * review * revert restriction renaming * fix language restrictions * lint * generate * allow custom texts for supported langs for now * fix tests * cleanup * cleanup * cleanup * lint * unsupported preferred lang is allowed * fix integration test * finish reverting to old property name * finish reverting to old property name * load languages * refactor(i18n): centralize translators and fs * lint * amplify no validations on preferred languages * fix integration test * lint * fix resetting allowed languages * test unchanged restrictions
2023-12-05 11:12:01 +00:00
}
allowedLanguages := restrictions.AllowedLanguages
if len(allowedLanguages) == 0 {
allowedLanguages = i18n.SupportedLanguages()
}
return op.NewResponse(s.createDiscoveryConfig(ctx, allowedLanguages)), nil
}
func (s *Server) VerifyAuthRequest(ctx context.Context, r *op.Request[oidc.AuthRequest]) (_ *op.ClientRequest[oidc.AuthRequest], err error) {
ctx, span := tracing.NewSpan(ctx)
defer func() { span.EndWithError(err) }()
return s.LegacyServer.VerifyAuthRequest(ctx, r)
}
func (s *Server) Authorize(ctx context.Context, r *op.ClientRequest[oidc.AuthRequest]) (_ *op.Redirect, err error) {
ctx, span := tracing.NewSpan(ctx)
defer func() { span.EndWithError(err) }()
return s.LegacyServer.Authorize(ctx, r)
}
func (s *Server) DeviceAuthorization(ctx context.Context, r *op.ClientRequest[oidc.DeviceAuthorizationRequest]) (_ *op.Response, err error) {
ctx, span := tracing.NewSpan(ctx)
defer func() { span.EndWithError(err) }()
return s.LegacyServer.DeviceAuthorization(ctx, r)
}
func (s *Server) Revocation(ctx context.Context, r *op.ClientRequest[oidc.RevocationRequest]) (_ *op.Response, err error) {
ctx, span := tracing.NewSpan(ctx)
defer func() { span.EndWithError(err) }()
return s.LegacyServer.Revocation(ctx, r)
}
func (s *Server) EndSession(ctx context.Context, r *op.Request[oidc.EndSessionRequest]) (_ *op.Redirect, err error) {
ctx, span := tracing.NewSpan(ctx)
defer func() { span.EndWithError(err) }()
return s.LegacyServer.EndSession(ctx, r)
}
feat: restrict languages (#6931) * feat: return 404 or 409 if org reg disallowed * fix: system limit permissions * feat: add iam limits api * feat: disallow public org registrations on default instance * add integration test * test: integration * fix test * docs: describe public org registrations * avoid updating docs deps * fix system limits integration test * silence integration tests * fix linting * ignore strange linter complaints * review * improve reset properties naming * redefine the api * use restrictions aggregate * test query * simplify and test projection * test commands * fix unit tests * move integration test * support restrictions on default instance * also test GetRestrictions * self review * lint * abstract away resource owner * fix tests * configure supported languages * fix allowed languages * fix tests * default lang must not be restricted * preferred language must be allowed * change preferred languages * check languages everywhere * lint * test command side * lint * add integration test * add integration test * restrict supported ui locales * lint * lint * cleanup * lint * allow undefined preferred language * fix integration tests * update main * fix env var * ignore linter * ignore linter * improve integration test config * reduce cognitive complexity * compile * check for duplicates * remove useless restriction checks * review * revert restriction renaming * fix language restrictions * lint * generate * allow custom texts for supported langs for now * fix tests * cleanup * cleanup * cleanup * lint * unsupported preferred lang is allowed * fix integration test * finish reverting to old property name * finish reverting to old property name * load languages * refactor(i18n): centralize translators and fs * lint * amplify no validations on preferred languages * fix integration test * lint * fix resetting allowed languages * test unchanged restrictions
2023-12-05 11:12:01 +00:00
func (s *Server) createDiscoveryConfig(ctx context.Context, supportedUILocales oidc.Locales) *oidc.DiscoveryConfiguration {
issuer := op.IssuerFromContext(ctx)
feat(oidc): use web keys for token signing and verification (#8449) # Which Problems Are Solved Use web keys, managed by the `resources/v3alpha/web_keys` API, for OIDC token signing and verification, as well as serving the public web keys on the jwks / keys endpoint. Response header on the keys endpoint now allows caching of the response. This is now "safe" to do since keys can be created ahead of time and caches have sufficient time to pickup the change before keys get enabled. # How the Problems Are Solved - The web key format is used in the `getSignerOnce` function in the `api/oidc` package. - The public key cache is changed to get and store web keys. - The jwks / keys endpoint returns the combined set of valid "legacy" public keys and all available web keys. - Cache-Control max-age default to 5 minutes and is configured in `defaults.yaml`. When the web keys feature is enabled, fallback mechanisms are in place to obtain and convert "legacy" `query.PublicKey` as web keys when needed. This allows transitioning to the feature without invalidating existing tokens. A small performance overhead may be noticed on the keys endpoint, because 2 queries need to be run sequentially. This will disappear once the feature is stable and the legacy code gets cleaned up. # Additional Changes - Extend legacy key lifetimes so that tests can be run on an existing database with more than 6 hours apart. - Discovery endpoint returns all supported algorithms when the Web Key feature is enabled. # Additional Context - Closes https://github.com/zitadel/zitadel/issues/8031 - Part of https://github.com/zitadel/zitadel/issues/7809 - After https://github.com/zitadel/oidc/pull/637 - After https://github.com/zitadel/oidc/pull/638
2024-08-23 12:43:46 +00:00
return &oidc.DiscoveryConfiguration{
Issuer: issuer,
AuthorizationEndpoint: s.Endpoints().Authorization.Absolute(issuer),
TokenEndpoint: s.Endpoints().Token.Absolute(issuer),
IntrospectionEndpoint: s.Endpoints().Introspection.Absolute(issuer),
UserinfoEndpoint: s.Endpoints().Userinfo.Absolute(issuer),
RevocationEndpoint: s.Endpoints().Revocation.Absolute(issuer),
EndSessionEndpoint: s.Endpoints().EndSession.Absolute(issuer),
JwksURI: s.Endpoints().JwksURI.Absolute(issuer),
DeviceAuthorizationEndpoint: s.Endpoints().DeviceAuthorization.Absolute(issuer),
ScopesSupported: op.Scopes(s.Provider()),
ResponseTypesSupported: op.ResponseTypes(s.Provider()),
ResponseModesSupported: []string{
string(oidc.ResponseModeQuery),
string(oidc.ResponseModeFragment),
string(oidc.ResponseModeFormPost),
},
GrantTypesSupported: op.GrantTypes(s.Provider()),
SubjectTypesSupported: op.SubjectTypes(s.Provider()),
feat(oidc): use web keys for token signing and verification (#8449) # Which Problems Are Solved Use web keys, managed by the `resources/v3alpha/web_keys` API, for OIDC token signing and verification, as well as serving the public web keys on the jwks / keys endpoint. Response header on the keys endpoint now allows caching of the response. This is now "safe" to do since keys can be created ahead of time and caches have sufficient time to pickup the change before keys get enabled. # How the Problems Are Solved - The web key format is used in the `getSignerOnce` function in the `api/oidc` package. - The public key cache is changed to get and store web keys. - The jwks / keys endpoint returns the combined set of valid "legacy" public keys and all available web keys. - Cache-Control max-age default to 5 minutes and is configured in `defaults.yaml`. When the web keys feature is enabled, fallback mechanisms are in place to obtain and convert "legacy" `query.PublicKey` as web keys when needed. This allows transitioning to the feature without invalidating existing tokens. A small performance overhead may be noticed on the keys endpoint, because 2 queries need to be run sequentially. This will disappear once the feature is stable and the legacy code gets cleaned up. # Additional Changes - Extend legacy key lifetimes so that tests can be run on an existing database with more than 6 hours apart. - Discovery endpoint returns all supported algorithms when the Web Key feature is enabled. # Additional Context - Closes https://github.com/zitadel/zitadel/issues/8031 - Part of https://github.com/zitadel/zitadel/issues/7809 - After https://github.com/zitadel/oidc/pull/637 - After https://github.com/zitadel/oidc/pull/638
2024-08-23 12:43:46 +00:00
IDTokenSigningAlgValuesSupported: supportedSigningAlgs(ctx),
RequestObjectSigningAlgValuesSupported: op.RequestObjectSigAlgorithms(s.Provider()),
TokenEndpointAuthMethodsSupported: op.AuthMethodsTokenEndpoint(s.Provider()),
TokenEndpointAuthSigningAlgValuesSupported: op.TokenSigAlgorithms(s.Provider()),
IntrospectionEndpointAuthSigningAlgValuesSupported: op.IntrospectionSigAlgorithms(s.Provider()),
IntrospectionEndpointAuthMethodsSupported: op.AuthMethodsIntrospectionEndpoint(s.Provider()),
RevocationEndpointAuthSigningAlgValuesSupported: op.RevocationSigAlgorithms(s.Provider()),
RevocationEndpointAuthMethodsSupported: op.AuthMethodsRevocationEndpoint(s.Provider()),
ClaimsSupported: op.SupportedClaims(s.Provider()),
CodeChallengeMethodsSupported: op.CodeChallengeMethods(s.Provider()),
feat: restrict languages (#6931) * feat: return 404 or 409 if org reg disallowed * fix: system limit permissions * feat: add iam limits api * feat: disallow public org registrations on default instance * add integration test * test: integration * fix test * docs: describe public org registrations * avoid updating docs deps * fix system limits integration test * silence integration tests * fix linting * ignore strange linter complaints * review * improve reset properties naming * redefine the api * use restrictions aggregate * test query * simplify and test projection * test commands * fix unit tests * move integration test * support restrictions on default instance * also test GetRestrictions * self review * lint * abstract away resource owner * fix tests * configure supported languages * fix allowed languages * fix tests * default lang must not be restricted * preferred language must be allowed * change preferred languages * check languages everywhere * lint * test command side * lint * add integration test * add integration test * restrict supported ui locales * lint * lint * cleanup * lint * allow undefined preferred language * fix integration tests * update main * fix env var * ignore linter * ignore linter * improve integration test config * reduce cognitive complexity * compile * check for duplicates * remove useless restriction checks * review * revert restriction renaming * fix language restrictions * lint * generate * allow custom texts for supported langs for now * fix tests * cleanup * cleanup * cleanup * lint * unsupported preferred lang is allowed * fix integration test * finish reverting to old property name * finish reverting to old property name * load languages * refactor(i18n): centralize translators and fs * lint * amplify no validations on preferred languages * fix integration test * lint * fix resetting allowed languages * test unchanged restrictions
2023-12-05 11:12:01 +00:00
UILocalesSupported: supportedUILocales,
RequestParameterSupported: s.Provider().RequestObjectSupported(),
}
}
perf(oidc): optimize token creation (#7822) * implement code exchange * port tokenexchange to v2 tokens * implement refresh token * implement client credentials * implement jwt profile * implement device token * cleanup unused code * fix current unit tests * add user agent unit test * unit test domain package * need refresh token as argument * test commands create oidc session * test commands device auth * fix device auth build error * implicit for oidc session API * implement authorize callback handler for legacy implicit mode * upgrade oidc module to working draft * add missing auth methods and time * handle all errors in defer * do not fail auth request on error the oauth2 Go client automagically retries on any error. If we fail the auth request on the first error, the next attempt will always fail with the Errors.AuthRequest.NoCode, because the auth request state is already set to failed. The original error is then already lost and the oauth2 library does not return the original error. Therefore we should not fail the auth request. Might be worth discussing and perhaps send a bug report to Oauth2? * fix code flow tests by explicitly setting code exchanged * fix unit tests in command package * return allowed scope from client credential client * add device auth done reducer * carry nonce thru session into ID token * fix token exchange integration tests * allow project role scope prefix in client credentials client * gci formatting * do not return refresh token in client credentials and jwt profile * check org scope * solve linting issue on authorize callback error * end session based on v2 session ID * use preferred language and user agent ID for v2 access tokens * pin oidc v3.23.2 * add integration test for jwt profile and client credentials with org scopes * refresh token v1 to v2 * add user token v2 audit event * add activity trigger * cleanup and set panics for unused methods * use the encrypted code for v1 auth request get by code * add missing event translation * fix pipeline errors (hopefully) * fix another test * revert pointer usage of preferred language * solve browser info panic in device auth * remove duplicate entries in AMRToAuthMethodTypes to prevent future `mfa` claim * revoke v1 refresh token to prevent reuse * fix terminate oidc session * always return a new refresh toke in refresh token grant --------- Co-authored-by: Livio Spring <livio.a@gmail.com>
2024-05-16 05:07:56 +00:00
func response(resp any, err error) (*op.Response, error) {
if err != nil {
return nil, err
}
return op.NewResponse(resp), nil
}